Tuesday, 9 September 2025

Shouldhood and Unsanity


‘Shouldhood' causes upset or increases the intensity of what, Albert 

Ellis calls, our ‘upsetness.’ The degree of ‘upsetness’ caused by our 

tendency to think in ‘shoulds’ is what Ellis also calls ‘shithood:’ 

‘shouldhood’ leads to ‘shithood ‘ psychologically speaking.

Sometimes we might ‘should’ and stop and rethink our ‘shoulding’ 

reminding ourselves that to demand we should get something we 

can’t get is futile. So, we recalibrate, shift our thinking to a more 

logical, rational posture.

However, if we indulge in ‘should’ thinking on a more permanent 

basis, where we continue to demand that things should, absolutely 

be as we demand they should be, then ‘shithood’ is where we end up 

until we understand how thinking effects how we feel and behave. 

The world is no good, others are no good and/or you are no good 

equals ‘SHITHOOD!”

‘Nothing is good or bad but thinking makes it so.’ Shakespeare (Hamlet)

The Have a Go Spaghettio! approach to social and emotional 

learning teaches early childhood constructivists that they can build 

and cultivate rational habits of thinking or what Have a Go 

Spaghettio! calls Success Helper or Brain Friend thinking. Students 

are taught about the Think – feel – do connection, that helpful, Brain 

Friend thinking makes Brain Friend feelings and behaviours.

Brain Bully thinking is characterised by should/ought/must thinking 

that causes Brain Bully feelings and behaviours. Some examples of 

BB thinking:

You must like me or I’m worthless!

I must always do well or I’m a failure!

The world should give me what I want or it’s not fair!

Have a Go Spaghettio! Is based on Rational Emotive Behaviour 

Therapy and General Semantics theories that say one cannot be what 

we think we should be according to others to be an OK person. 

Relying on others approval is a Brain Bully construct (I should be as 

others say I should be – good, smart, cute, dumb etc)

Alfred Korzybski, creator of General Semantics theory, talks about 

sanity and ‘unsanity.’ Brain Bully thinking causes ‘unsanity’ where 

the person resides psychologically until they identify, challenge, and 

change their beliefs to more sane, rational, Brain Friend beliefs. I 

think the state of ‘unsanity’ is Albert Ellis’ condition of ‘shouldhood’ 

both characterised by  irrational, Brain Bully beliefs. Unsanity, 

shouldhood leads to shithood!

So, Have a Go Spaghettio! will help young learners avoid the 

ravages of ‘shoudlhood’ if they learn about Brain Friend, Success 

Helper ways of thinking and if they arrive in ‘shithood’ at times they 

will know they are there and why and will be able to extricate 

themselves and manage adversity in a reasonable, Brain Friend 

thinking way!

Give a try Banana Pie!


 

Shouldhood and Unsanity

‘Shouldhood' causes upset or increases the intensity of what, Albert  Ellis calls, our ‘upsetness.’ The degree of ‘upsetness’ caused by ...